« Creative Uses for Mirrors | MAIN | Breast Cancer Awareness Month »

October 15, 2009
Clutter VS Layered

I've noticed a few comments on our site from readers who think a room is too "cluttered" for their taste. While, everyone is entitled to their own decorating opinion -- it has made me wonder is one mans clutter another man's clever display?

51563-creative-display-r-x

Just the other week we were talking to designer Joe Minton (who designed the interiors for the 2009 Southern Accents showhouse) and someone asked the question, "what is the difference between layering and just clutter?" His answer was, "proportion and their relationship to one another."

But what does that really mean?


Here is one room that a reader has described as "too cluttered":


2-velvet-sofa-xl

This room does have a lot going on -- bright colors, lots of varied textures, and the mirrored wall reflects it all almost doubling the effect. But everything in this room does have a relation to something. First, look at the symmetry and balance. 2 chrome étagères, the books are in small stacks and balanced on both sides, and 2 side tables flanking the sofa (one bamboo and one drop-leaf). Even if this is NOT your taste-- the room does have proportion and balance.

53183-fabulous-frame-r-l

This wall of art definitely makes a statement and takes this black-and-white color combo to the next level. The reason the room works is the connection and relation the framed photos have with one another. They all have black frames and are hung with similar spacing.

35dd734fff7b24034efbf78ed745159cc5454b37_m_large

The same principles apply here-- the pattern of frame sizes keeps this grid interesting and the common framing and subject matter help make this cluster work as one art installment.

So, how do you successfully achieve a well-edited layered look rather than just a bunch of clutter?

  • First, remove everything from the table, the wall, the shelf and lay out your accents. Group your items by theme-- color, texture, size to help.This will help to create the relationship between pieces.
  • Then start by putting one up at a time. Keep in mind the principles of symmetry-- something big on one end is balanced out with something large on the other (they don't have to be the same thing either).
  • Second -- play with height. Mix in a tall candle stick or put a framed photo on top of a stack of books to add some height. You want to create a display that is interesting and not predictable-- this will do just that.

20090108190042

20090815062903

The most important thing is to know when enough is enough-- you don't have to put EVERYTHING out all at once. If you love a certain vase, but it is making the table too cluttered -- move to a new room. If you can't see the surface of a table or shelf -- you may have too much. Pull two-or-three things and see if that helps. 

(Photos: Cottage Living, MyHomeIdeas, Coastal Living,

We Heart It, Absolutely Beautiful Things, We Heart It)

|
Comments

I'm a graphic designer who has worked with hundreds of clients over the years. It is my experience that folks often say "it's too cluttered" when they can't quite put their finger on what they really want to say. That said - image number two?

"It's too cluttered"

;-)

Posted by:LaurelStreet | October 15, 2009 at 11:25 AM

Very good post.
Many a times, it's the "clutter" that actually enhances the surroundings, and lends an interesting look to the space.

Posted by:Toronto Furniture Deals | October 15, 2009 at 01:34 PM
Post a comment

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In








Contributors
Jennifer Bonds
Zoë Gowen
Abbi Masters
Lydia Somerville
Riley Tant
Kim Turnbull Alexander
Dawn Russell Williams